Even as a non-attorney, I am aware of the advice: If you
have the facts, pound them, if not, pound the table. The "table" of
compassion and idealism has been pounded hard in recent letters on
immigration, now with reference to religious forgiveness regarding
illegals. The question could be raised why Law should adhere to
Christian principles here when they are being abandoned in so many other
areas. But, even a Supreme Being cannot allow mercy to rob justice (or common
sense), even with forgiveness, otherwise God would cease to be That.
Even allowing for the sincerity of these advocates, compassion and
charity work best for private individuals and groups, not as government
policy. When done at the latter level the question: "At whose expense?",
always has to be raised. Pres. Bush's recent "donation" of aids funds
for Africa is not wholly virtuous or at all as the extraction from
taxpayers is not voluntary whereas private donations would be.
Similarly, excessive immigration policy that purports to be
compassionate comes at a great price and effect to existing citizens. True charity does not come
at the expense of others. Also, recipients of compassion and forgiveness
should display an element of remorse and refrain from repeating the
offense. Many come here explicitly to take advantage of US and our
benefits in some way and with Mexico, it has become a calculated policy.
To reward illegals with amnesties or in other ways who deliberately and
arrogantly "crowd to the front of the line" of those patiently waiting
to enter legally with fiat forgiveness is unjust, unearned and only
encourages more of the same behavior and makes a mockery of the legal
process. The sanction of deportation is required to bring order, justice
and discipline to immigration policy as well as the need for reduced
numbers of legal admissions ( A "time-out" period could be justified ).
This would display rare compassion for American citizens and respect for
their rights and concerns.
R. L. Ranger
Share this page
Bookmark this page
The leading immigration law publisher - over 50000 pages of free information!
© Copyright 1995- American Immigration LLC, ILW.COM