In Berishaj v. Ashcroft, No. 03-1338 (3rd Cir. Aug. 5, 2004), the 3rd
Circuit makes a number of critical points which echo themes Immigration
Daily (and practically no one else) has sounded before. The particular
problem that concerned the court in this case was the out-of-date
documentation in the record for the asylum petition:
"Considering the rapid, frequent political changes in countries from which
asylum and CAT applicants usually come, and the potentially dire
consequences of sending such an applicant back to his country of origin to
face possible persecution or torture on the basis of such a stale report,
we call on Congress, the Department of Justice, the Department of Homeland
Security, and the BIA to improve the structure and operation of the system,
so that all may have the confidence that the ultimate disposition of a
removal case bears a meaningful connection to the merits of the petitioner’s claim(s) in light of contemporary world affairs."
As to why the current system produces out-of-date records, the 3rd Circuit
hit the nail on the head: the Affirmance Without Opinion (AWO) procedure at
the BIA a.k.a. the streamlining regulation. While the circuit courts have
found this procedure to be legal, Immigration Daily has pointed out
numerous times that it overburdens the Circuit Courts and jeopardizes their
functioning. Without calling for wholesale rejection of the AWO procedure,
the 3rd Circuit does ask the BIA to act:
"The trigger for the recent spate of out-of-date records is, we suspect,
the streamlining regulations noted above, which permit the BIA to summarily
affirm an IJ’s decision without issuing its own opinion. See 8 C.F.R. §
3.1(e)(4). The natural—though surely unintended—consequence of the
streamlining regulations is summary affirmance by the BIA of stale,
backlogged decisions by IJs. When it does so, the BIA may have shirked its
role and duty of ensuring that the final agency determination in an
immigration case is reasonably sound and reasonably current. ... The
streamlining regulations exist to save an overburdened BIA from unnecessary
and redundant tasks. They are not a license for the BIA to say “not our
problem.” Outdated administrative records are the BIA’s problem, at least
as things now stand, and the BIA needs to confront them. We therefore call
on the BIA to adopt—by opinion, regulation, or otherwise—policies that will
avoid the Court of Appeals having to review administrative records so
out-of-date as to verge on meaningless."
The real issue is that summary removal is not in keeping with our country's
tradition of due process, and due process necessarily means an expensive
and lengthy proceeding which will usually be of great advantage to aliens.
The answer to the massive volume of cases flooding the immigration courts
is to open up massive avenues of legal immigration - attempts at massive
deportation will succeed only in destroying the foundations of our own
government. The fundamental problem at this level of policy is always the
procedure, here is what the 3rd Circuit says, quite rightly, it should not
do (and what the pre-AWO BIA would have done).
"we will not scour a 700-plus page record (well over half of which is
devoted to documentary materials) for evidence unnoticed and unanalyzed by
the IJ to uphold the IJ’s decision."
Bear in mind that the 3rd Circuit is hardly acting here in the alien's
interests. Recognizing that "in the majority, country conditions had
improved, weaking the alien's case for relief" the court says "we encourage
the Department of Justice to adopt a policy that encourages its attorneys
to file motions to reopen when the adjudication of an applicant’s claim
would benefit from an updated administrative record."
The bottom line is that the "deport-'em-all" mentality that dominates in
the post-9/11 DOJ/DHS appears to believe that there is no baby in the bath
water to be thrown out. Immigration is good for America, and so is due
process, and so of course is security. There will not be any due process
conflict with large-scale, secure, channels of legal immigration. It is
only when anti-immigrationists seek to artificially restrict natural
immigration that these due process conflicts arise. Those who fear what
large scale immigration can do to America have as little confidence in our
country as the America-hating multi-culturalists do. The USA deserves
Advertising In Immigration Daily
- We are the only daily immigration law periodical -- your ad will appear in three (3) places: in our email newsletter, on our web site, and in our archives.
- We offer a targeted audience -- with 14,000+ subscribers, what better place to advertise your legal hiring needs or your immigration-related services?
- We offer national coverage -- unlike regional or local newspapers, ILW.COM readers span the globe.
- We provide fast service -- since we are a web-based organzation, we are quick and nimble.
- We provide you with guidance -- we offer suggestions to your ad text to maximize its effectiveness.
For more info. see:
How Do I Place An Ad? |
Place Your Ad Now
The Endless Wait: Will Resources Match The Resolve To Reduce The Immigration Case Backlog?
The Immigration Policy Center of the American Immigration Law Foundation writes "Congress and the White House have pledged for a decade to reduce the backlog of immigration cases, but without providing the resources necessary to do the job."
Keep on top of the latest in immigration law! Attend ILW.COM seminars! You can attend ILW.COM phone seminars from the convenience of your office! For more info on the seminars currently available, please click here: http://www.ilw.com/seminars/
Immigration Law News
Government Has Burden Of Showing Changed Country Conditions
In Berishaj v. Ashcroft, No. 03-1338 (3rd Cir. Aug. 5, 2004), the court said that the IJ's opinion in this asylum matter was cursory, thinly reasoned and discussed the case without any reference to the governing legal standards. The court also said that the comments of the IJ were not tethered to the record, owing what little support they had to hyperbole and appeals to popular culture, which the court characterized as two utterly bases for an asylum decision.
DOS Cable On Prospective Students Entering On B Visas
The Department of State issued a cable correcting previous guidance on prospective students entering on a B visa.
AILA Executive Director On CNN's Lou Dobbs Tonight
A transcript of CNN's "Lou Dobbs Tonight" reports AILA's Executive Director Jeanne Butterfield as saying, "But what I'm saying, Lou, is our borders are our last line of defense. Lets make sure that we work with Canada and Mexico, to make sure that they're doing the proper screening, so that bad guys don't even get there, let alone get to the Rio Grande."
Attorney listings on ILW.COM are searched 200,000 times/year! Each attorney listed is searched an average of once each day! Just one new client will pay for the entire year's fee! Click here for more info: http://www.ilw.com/membership/
Immigration Law Conferences
DHS has issued new Section 343 rules requiring foreign health care workers who are seeking temporary or permanent occupational visas or Trade NAFTA status to obtain a special visa certification in order to provide health care services in this country. The Commission on Graduates of Foreign Nursing Schools (CGFNS)/International Commission on Healthcare Professions (ICHP) are sponsoring a special educational program in your community about the new DHS rules. The new federal DHS rules apply to: Registered nurses and licensed practical (vocational) nurses, Audiologists, Physical Therapists, Medical Technicians, Occupational Therapists, Medical Laboratory Technologists, Speech-Language Pathologists, Physician Assistants. Upcoming session locations include: Miami, FL - Monday, Aug. 23, Philadelphia, PA- Monday, Aug.16, Seattle, WA - Monday, Sept. 27, New York, NY - Monday, Oct. 4, San Francisco, CA - Monday, Oct. 18th, Atlanta, GA - Monday, Nov. 1st. To register, contact Marla Downing at: email@example.com, (ph) 215-222-8454, x.242, or visit http://www.cgfns.org/cgfns/newsandevents/specialevents.html
We carry advertisements for Help Wanted: Attorney, Help Wanted: Paralegal, Help Wanted: Other, Positions Sought, Products & Services Offered, etc.
For information on advertising in the classifieds please click here
For a listing of current immigration events please click here
For services/products of use in your law practice please click here
Letters to the Editor
Readers are welcome to share their comments, email: firstname.lastname@example.org.
There is a lot of debate recently to not only halt illegal immigration but to possibly do the same with legal immigration. I support a permanent bar to any amnesty that rewards illegal immigration and a very thorough screening of all legal immigrants. I know Chucky's ambitious proposal to ban the H-1B visa is unlikely to pass but it should help put some pressure on Congress to not raise the H-1B cap when there is no justification.
An Important disclaimer! The information provided on this page is not legal advice.
Transmission of this information is not intended to create, and receipt by you does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Readers must not act upon any information without first seeking advice from a
qualified attorney. Send Correspondence and articles to email@example.com. Letters and articles may be edited and may be published and otherwise used in any medium. Opinions expressed in letters and articles do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.