ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Advanced search

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network


Chinese Immig. Daily


Connect to us

Make us Homepage



The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of free

Immigration LLC.

< Back to current issue of Immigration Daily < Back to current issue of Immigrant's Weekly

America Dreamed

by Rosa Martha Villarreal

Perhaps it is only appropriate to begin a conversation about the future of illegal immigrants in America with a reference to the Mexican anthropologist Guillermo Bónfil Batalla and his insights about what constitutes a "civilization project." Appropriate because it is not lost on the American public that it's our neighbor Mexico that has made the most significant contribution to this population and because Mexico's recent nationalistic rhetoric has arouse skepticism, fear, and contempt in the American public. A prominent argument among the fiercest opponents of normalization of this illegal population---or, to use a politically incorrect term, amnesty---is that Mexican nationals constitute a threat to the very core of what it means to be an American. This is where Professor Bónfil Batalla's definition provides a provocative point for discussion.

When Bónfil Batalla coined the term "México profundo," he divided the national consciousness in terms of nationalistic, political project which began when Mexico declared its independence from Spain, replete with all of the symbolism of a nation-state. He then described the other Mexico, the composed of the spirit and aspirations of its native peoples and their worldview. This, said, Bónfil Batalla, was the true collective soul, the true nation, uncorrupted, real because it has been dreamed, and stifled by the machinations of the political system.

Ironically enough, one can say that there, too, is an American equivalent to this world of the profound. Except that, reflecting the character of Americanism, the definition evolved not from the intelligentsia, but from the soul of the people, the descendants of immigrant peasants: The American Dream. As a loyal American of Mexican descent, I take personal offense at the misappropriation of this cherished concept by extremists and special interest groups in America, misguided and mettlesome Mexican intellectuals, and cynical Mexican government officials. I am annoyed with the aforementioned folks because they regard the American Dream as the equivalent to an employment agency.

As I remind my students at the college where I teach, the American Dream was and is the fulfillment of the desire that the individual could be free to aspire to his most profound desires regardless of his background, his bloodlines, and pedigrees. The American Dream is the Jeffersonian trust in the wisdom of the people, not the ruling class, and certainly not the intelligentsia, who, although well-meaning, are frequently so disconnected from the lives of common men and women that their concern is perceived as patronizing, and correctly so.

The American Dream is the elevation of the individual over the group. Though one's past is an integral part of one's identity-a position I reiterated as a creative writer as the Mexican landscape dominates my fiction---the manner in which one's ethnic identity is recalled is ultimately the spiritual project of the individual. For example, my parents were born in Mexico and immigrated (yes, legally) in 1954. Being well-versed in the history of both countries, I consider the conduct of my country (U.S.A) in the Mexican-American war to be less than honorable. However, I harbor neither resentments nor irredentist desires. Though right-wing interlocutors have tried to smear Americans of Mexican descent as anti-Semites because of the support of some radical Chicano groups for the Palestinian cause, I am a supporter of Israel. My sympathy is based less on the fact that my ancestors were Spanish Jews who like today's Israelis faced an existential dilemma, but, rather, on my personal political convictions of supporting a liberal democracy in a sea of dictatorships. This is the spiritual aspect of the American Dream: I can create my own identity and shape my own convictions and not be beholden to traditionalism or group-think. Regrettably, the position voiced by both the Mexican government and members of the Mexican intelligentsia is that because my parents were born in Mexico, my loyalties should and interests should lie with Mexico. My creative fascination with Mexico, yes; my political loyalties, no.

Which brings me back to the initial problem facing the American body politic: what to do with the millions of men and women and their children living illegally in America? Should we give them amnesty? Perhaps that is the only humane and workable solution. But this is the opportunity for the body politic to articulate what it means to be an American versus an American citizen. To be an American is to embrace the America that is desired and dreamed. The American dream signifies the freedom to define, create, and if necessary, recreate the self. Perhaps what is most frustrating to me is that in this debate about illegal immigration is that people of Mexican descent have been cynically defined as a group rather than individuals. How ironic.

About The Author

Rosa Martha Villarreal is a descendent of several founding families of early Spanish colonies. She is the author of acclaimed historical novel, Chronicles of Air and Dreams: A Novel of Mexico, and most recently The Stillness of Love and Exile (Tertulia Press, May 2007). For more info, visit

The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.