Physician Immigration Takes Center Stage In Washington
Note: This article went to print on July 10, 2006. Legislative updates may have occurred since that
While the public is generally focused on building a fence on the U.S.-Mexican border and legalizing
millions of undocumented immigrants, Congress is considering several measures that will have an
important impact on physician immigration.
In order to practice in the U.S., a foreign medical graduate (FMG) must undergo graduate medical training
in the U.S. Approximately 6,000 FMGs enter the U.S. each year for residency training, filling roughly
one-quarter of the 25,000+ training positions.
More than half of those doctors enter with a J-1 visa. Unless a waiver is secured, a J-1 is obligated to
return to his or her home country for a two-year period following completion of a program. The growing
physician shortage and the increased realization that FMGs can play a critical role in addressing the health
care needs of the public have led Congress to liberalize the requirements for securing waivers. Some
employers have been reluctant to go through the J-1 waiver process due to the expense and the perceived
difficulties in the process, but the easing of some of the rules and the dwindling physician supply have
made many reconsider their positions.
Most of the remaining doctors coming to train in the U.S. enter on the H-1B visa. This visa is generally
perceived to be for high-tech workers, but it is open to any professional. The H-1B category has a general
cap of 65,000 visas issued per year, and the demand for the visa has been so strong that the quota is
usually used up months in advance. Unlike the J-1, there is no home residency requirement associated
with the H-1B. However, to secure an H-1B visa the applicant must pass USMLE part 3. In addition, the
H-1B visa is limited to six years, so for longer training programs, a physician can run into problems
maintaining legal status for the duration of the training and into a post-training position.
Expiration of the Conrad Program for Doctors Working in Underserved Areas
Congress will soon address many looming physician immigration issues. First on the priority list is
dealing with the June 1, 2006 expiration of the Conrad 30 J-1 physician waiver. This program allows a
state to sponsor up to 30 physicians annually to remain in the U.S. upon completion of their training
programs. Physicians willing to work in medically underserved communities for three years can avoid the
requirement that they return to their home countries for two years.
All 50 states now have their own participating programs, and the Conrad doctors now account for the vast
majority of J-1 waivers. The Conrad 30 programís expiration does not mean the immediate end of these
waivers. Any physicians in the U.S. on June 1, 2006, will still be able to seek waivers, so the death of the
program will not likely be noticed for a couple of years.
In all probability, however, it wonít be too long before Congress extends the Conrad 30 waiver. The
comprehensive immigration reform bill, ever-present in the news this year, contains a provision
permanently extending the Conrad program. And in the event that this massive piece of legislation doesnít pass, permanent reauthorization language is included in separate standalone bills that were introduced in
both the House and Senate. The House had its first hearing on the measure on May 18, 2006, and heard
from a representative of the Association of American Medical Colleges regarding the physician shortage
as well as an official from the General Accounting Office who testified that most states are pleased with
The Conrad Program once supplemented various federal waiver programs run by the U.S. Department of
Agriculture, Housing and Urban Development, Veterans Administration, and Appalachian Regional
Commission. Today, most waivers are Conrad 30 waivers. A new eight-state program by the Delta
Regional Authority is gaining strength, buoyed by 2004 legislative changes permitting the agency to
sponsor specialist physicians. And the VA program is still very much alive. But the Appalachian Regional
Commission and the Health and Human Services waiver programs are now only approving a very small
number of cases.
More Slots for Larger States
Aside from permanently extending the Conrad program, several other proposals are being promoted for
inclusion in the standalone legislation. First, advocates are urging Congress to include language to permit
leftover waiver slots to be reclaimed by populous states such as Texas and New York. An exemption from
the employment-based green card cap for doctors who have worked in underserved communities is being
pushed (right now, the wait for Indian and Chinese doctors can be several years due to green card
backlogs). Measures designed to give favorable treatment to communities in Hurricane Katrina-affected
parts of the country are on the table. And an exemption from the H-1B visa quota for doctors working in
medically underserved communities is being discussed.
Increasing Work Visa and Green Card Availability
The Conrad 30 legislation is the only physician-specific legislation currently being debated, but several
other bills would have a significant effect.
The comprehensive immigration reform legislation noted above passed in the Senate just after Memorial
Day and has a provision that would expand the number of H-1B visas from 65,000 per year to 115,000
per year. The cap could grow by up to 20 percent per year if demand for the H-1B is high.
That legislation would be important to doctors because an increasingly large number of international
medical graduates are entering the country each year on H-1B visas instead of J-1s. When these doctors
complete their training, they generally become subject to the annual H-1B quota. The unavailability of
visas for doctors completing their training is a problem that continues to grow.
The bill also expands employment-based green card numbers. Under the comprehensive immigration
reform bill pending in the Senate, the number of employment-based green cards would more than double.
The per-country limit requiring that no more than 7 percent of visas in a particular green card category go
to members of a particular nationality would rise to 10 percent and would immediately free up visas for
many (particularly Indians and Chinese).
Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX), chair of the Senate Immigration Subcommittee, recently introduced the
Securing Knowledge, Innovation, and Leadership Act of 2006 or SKIL Act. The SKIL Act would also
expand the H-1B visa for doctors. First, the actual numbers of H-1Bs would rise to 115,000 and could
grow up to 20 percent each year if the cap is fully used in a year. The bill would also exempt those who
complete U.S. graduate programs from the H-1B cap, and those who complete foreign countriesí graduate
programs could tap into a 20,000 bonus quota. That would free up many H-1Bs for those currently
affected by the cap. Finally, the bill exempts specialist physicians from the H-1B cap, and it would expand
green card availability along lines largely similar to the comprehensive immigration reform package.
While the Conrad program will likely be extended, other legislative changes will face a tough fight. But as
the physician shortage in the nation worsens, the politics in favor of physician immigration improve,
which provides an arena for more serious consideration of other solutions.
This article originally appeared in Recruiting Physicians Today, a newsletter published by The New England Journal of Medicine, in the issue of July-August 2006.
About The Author
Greg Siskind is a partner at Siskind Susser, a national immigration law firm. is a partner in Siskind Susser's Memphis, Tennessee, office. After graduating magna cum laude from Vanderbilt University, he received his Juris Doctorate from the University of Chicago. Mr. Siskind is a member of AILA, a board member of the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, and a member of the ABA, where he serves on the LPM Publishing Board as Marketing Vice Chairman. He is the author of several books, including the J Visa Guidebook and The Lawyer's Guide to Marketing on the Internet. Mr. Siskind practices all areas of immigration law, specializing in immigration matters of the health care and technology industries. He can be reached by email at firstname.lastname@example.org.
The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.
Share this page
Bookmark this page
The leading immigration law publisher - over 50000 pages of free information!
© Copyright 1995- American Immigration LLC, ILW.COM